An unofficial blog that watches Google's attempts to move your operating system online since 2005. Not affiliated with Google.

Send your tips to

May 19, 2007

Google Korea to Verify the Age for Adult Queries

Google intends to comply to the local law from Korea and ask users to confirm they're at least 19 if they use one of the 700 adult queries defined by the Korean government. Google's reason is that every other search engine and portal that operates in Korea does that. You can see what happens if you search for "sex" in Yahoo Korea. To verify your age, you need to enter your name and your national resident registration number, an unique identifier.

Google wants to increase its local presence in Korea to compete with search engines like Naver that dominate Korea's market. But they can't do that without respecting the law, even if it's absurd.

That's a tough challenge for a company that cares about ethics, but they already made their decision when Google started to censor the search results in China.

It's also interesting to note that Korean search engines mix the content from a lot of specialized search engines in one page and often images, videos and news are at the top of the page, while web pages are somewhere at the bottom of the page. Also Q&A sites similar to Yahoo Answers are very popular in Korea.

An article published last year by Associated Press explained why Koreans don't prefer Google:
Google has seeped into many aspects of online life across the globe, but the Internet search engine has failed so far to make any notable inroads in one of the world's most-wired countries: South Korea. Users here are some of the most Internet-savvy in the world, with millions of people running their own blogs and taking advantage of omnipresent broadband hookups and Wi-Fi hotspots. South Koreans would seem like natural Google users, but the leading search engine is merely a bit player.

Experts say Google's struggles here stem from unique factors in the Korean market, as well as Google's reliance on its software rather than human expertise to get search results. The Korean slice of the Web is relatively small compared to the English-language chunks of cyberspace. Koreans often come up short when trying to find information in their native tongue. To remedy the situation, Naver — which is more like a Yahoo-esque portal than a mere search engine — came up with what it calls Knowledge iN, where users post questions that are answered by other users — creating a database that now totals more than 41.1 million entries. (...)

"Google's site is just not enough for everything. Their search results especially are too limited," said [a Korean student]. "I think Google is paying less attention to Korean Internet users' demands."


  1. I don't think enforcing age verification for certain content is necessarily "absurd" (depends on what those 700 words are).

    The real concern here, however, is whether a user's searches for these terms is tied to their national ID number. Is Google logging the ID number along with the search terms, or merely flagging the user as "old enough"?

  2. Your criticizing for Google for enforcing query restrictions that lead to adult content?

    Would you like to criticize adult video stores for asking for ID before they sell porn to a 14-year-old?

  3. Yes, let's keep the kids ignorant about their sexuality. Wonderful idea. Perish the thought that healthy curiosity would be pandered to. Much better to endure the resulting STD's, unwanted pregnancies and guilt.

  4. Yes, I agree with all of you here so far (zimmer, jonathon, anonymous). Sex is dirty and NO ONE should be curious about it, especially kids. Guilt and puritanism RULE!!!

  5. is it puritanism to keep your 11 year old from looking up images of "man fisting ass"?

  6. If your 11 year old is looking up "man fisting ass" then you have much bigger problems. That is not natural healthy curiosity.. Something has gone horribly wrong.

    Having Google filter the results at this point is pointless.